Valim Book a call

Ex-Big Four CPA led, AI-enabled tax services for modern businesses & individuals.

Blog

RSUs vs stock options: how the taxes differ, and which is better

With RSUs vs stock options, the tax differs in timing. RSUs are taxed as wages when shares arrive, options when you exercise or sell. Here is how they compare.

Vishant Mehta, CPA, Ex-Big 4

Published

  • RSUs
  • stock options
  • NSOs
  • ISOs
  • equity compensation

Watch in 3 minutes

RSUs and stock options are taxed at different moments. Restricted stock units (RSUs) are taxed as wages on their full value when the shares are delivered, usually the day they vest. Stock options are taxed only when you act: nonqualified stock options (NSOs) at exercise, and incentive stock options (ISOs) mostly when you sell.

Neither one wins on tax in every case. RSUs usually cost nothing and keep some value at any share price, but the vesting schedule picks your tax year. Options can expire worthless, but you choose when to exercise, and ISOs can turn the whole gain into long-term capital gain.

RSU taxFull value at delivery, as wages
NSO taxThe spread at exercise, as wages
ISO tax at exerciseNone, but the spread counts for AMT
ISO long-term gainSell over 2 years after grant and 1 year after exercise
RSU and NSO withholding22%, or 37% over $1 million
Rules checkedNovember 3, 2026

How are RSUs and stock options taxed?

The tax comes at a different point for each, and every sale is taxed as a capital gain or loss. Here is how each works.

  1. RSUs. Nothing is taxed at grant, because an RSU is only a promise to deliver shares later. When the shares arrive, their value is wages on your W-2, with Social Security and Medicare tax. You cannot make an 83(b) election on RSUs.
  2. NSOs. Nothing is taxed at grant in the usual case. When you exercise, the spread (the share value minus your exercise price) is wages, with Social Security and Medicare tax. You also pay the exercise price in cash.
  3. ISOs. No regular income tax and no Social Security or Medicare tax are due at exercise. If you still hold the shares on December 31, the spread counts toward the alternative minimum tax (AMT).
  4. The sale, for all three. The gain or loss is the sale price minus your basis. For RSUs, basis is the value already taxed. For options, it is the price you paid plus any spread taxed as wages.

Is it better to get RSUs or stock options?

It depends on the share price, your spare cash and how much control you want over timing. Take 1,000 RSUs against 1,000 NSOs with a $20 exercise price.

Share price1,000 RSUs1,000 NSOs at $20
$15$15,000 of wagesWorth nothing, no tax
$50$50,000 of wages$30,000 of wages
$100$100,000 of wages$80,000 of wages

The NSO holder also pays $20,000 to exercise. RSUs keep value when the price falls, and options gain more, in percentage terms, when it rises.

Hold ISO shares more than 2 years from grant and 1 year from exercise, and the whole gain is long-term. Long-term gains are taxed at 0%, 15% or 20%, against wage rates of up to 37%. The trade-off is the AMT and the cash you tie up.

What are the disadvantages of RSUs?

The main disadvantage of RSUs is that you owe tax on their full value when the shares arrive, whether you sell them or not.

  • You cannot pick the year. The vesting schedule decides the year, even one when your other pay is high.
  • Withholding often falls short. Employers usually withhold 22%, but the 22% bracket ends at $105,700 single and $211,400 joint in 2026. Above it, the 22% leaves a balance to pay at filing.
  • A later drop does not cut the tax. If the price falls after delivery, the wages stay taxed. The drop is a capital loss, which offsets capital gains but only $3,000 of other income a year.
  • Your broker may report the wrong basis. For awards granted after 2013, Form 1099-B leaves out the income already taxed. Without a fix on Form 8949, you pay tax twice.

For example, a single filer with $250,000 of other taxable income who vests $100,000 owes about $34,800 of income tax on it. At 22%, only $22,000 is withheld.

One thing the IRS forms leave unclear: the Form 8949 instructions describe the basis fix only for stock options. The broker rule behind it also covers RSU shares, so the same code B correction applies.

What are the disadvantages of stock options?

Stock options cost cash to exercise, and they expire worthless if the share price stays below your exercise price. Read when to exercise stock options.

  • NSOs tax you before you sell. The spread is wages in the year you exercise, even if the price later falls.
  • ISOs can trigger the AMT. A large exercise kept past December 31 can bring an AMT bill with no cash from a sale to pay it.
  • ISO rules are strict. Only employees get ISOs, and you must exercise within 3 months after leaving to keep ISO treatment. Options on over $100,000 of stock first exercisable in one year are NSOs for the excess, valued at grant.
  • An early ISO sale costs the benefit. Sell before the 2-year and 1-year marks, and the spread becomes ordinary income in the year of sale, up to your actual gain.

When does each step happen?

WhenWhat happens
Each vesting dateRSU shares arrive and are taxed as wages
The day you exerciseThe NSO spread is taxed as wages
December 31, 2026ISO shares still held count for the 2026 AMT
January 15, 2027Fourth 2026 estimated payment due
April 15, 2027File your 2026 return

What should you do now?

  • List each grant, with its vesting dates and any exercise price.
  • For RSUs, compare the 22% withheld with your own bracket, and pay estimated tax on the gap.
  • For options, compare the exercise price with today's share value.
  • Before you exercise ISOs, estimate the AMT on the shares you plan to keep.
  • When you sell, check the basis on Form 1099-B against the income on your W-2.

See our guides to RSU taxes, NSO taxes and ISO taxes, compare ISOs and NSOs, or meet our equity compensation CPAs.

Sources.