Valim Book a call

Ex-Big Four CPA led, AI-enabled tax services for modern businesses & individuals.

Blog

ISO vs NSO: how each is taxed, and which is better

ISO vs NSO comes down to timing. An NSO's spread is taxed as wages at exercise, and an ISO owes no regular tax until you sell. Here is which one is better.

Vishant Mehta, CPA, Ex-Big 4

Published

  • ISOs
  • NSOs
  • stock options
  • AMT
  • equity compensation

Watch in 4 minutes

ISO vs NSO comes down to when you pay tax, and which taxes apply. A non-qualified stock option (NSO) is taxed at exercise: the spread, the share value minus your exercise price, counts as wages. An incentive stock option (ISO) owes no regular income tax at exercise, and never any Social Security or Medicare tax.

On tax alone, ISOs usually win, if you can afford to hold the shares 2 years from grant and 1 year from exercise. Then the whole gain is long-term. The catch is the alternative minimum tax (AMT) on ISO shares you still hold on December 31.

RuleISONSO
Who can get themEmployees onlyEmployees, contractors and directors
Tax at exerciseNone, but the spread counts for AMTThe spread, as wages
Social Security and MedicareNeverOn the spread
Long-term gainHold 2 years from grant, 1 from exerciseHold over 1 year after exercise
Yearly limit$100,000 of stock, valued at grantNone
Tax formForm 3921W-2, box 12, code V

Rules and figures checked on November 13, 2026.

What is the difference between an NSO and ISO?

An NSO and an ISO differ in when tax is due, which taxes apply and who can receive them. Here are the five differences that matter.

  1. Tax at exercise. An NSO's spread is ordinary income the year you exercise, even if you keep the shares. An ISO exercise creates no regular income tax.
  2. Payroll tax and withholding. The NSO spread owes 6.2% Social Security tax up to $184,500 of 2026 wages, plus 1.45% Medicare tax. Above $200,000 of wages ($250,000 on a joint return), Medicare tax rises by 0.9%. Employers may withhold a flat 22%, and must withhold 37% on supplemental wages over $1 million. ISOs need neither.
  3. The AMT. The ISO spread counts as AMT income if you hold the shares past year end. The 2026 exemption is $90,100 single and $140,200 joint.
  4. The sale. Hold ISO shares long enough, and the whole gain over your exercise price is long-term. NSO shares start a new holding period at exercise.
  5. The company's deduction. The company deducts the NSO spread as pay, but gets no deduction for an ISO unless you sell early.

How are ISOs and NSOs taxed on the same grant?

Take 10,000 options with a $5 exercise price, exercised when the shares are worth $25 and sold later at $40. The spread at exercise is $200,000 either way.

StepNSOISO, held long enough
Exercise at $25$200,000 of wagesNo regular tax, $200,000 for AMT
Payroll taxOn the $200,000None
Sale at $40$150,000 capital gain$350,000 long-term gain

Your NSO basis is $25 a share, but brokers report $5 for grants after 2013, so fix it on Form 8949. Sell the ISO shares within a year of exercise, and $200,000 is ordinary income, still free of payroll tax, plus $150,000 of short-term gain.

Do employees get ISOs or NSOs?

Employees can get either, but only employees can get ISOs. Your grant agreement says which you hold. Contractors, advisors and directors who are not employees can get only NSOs.

To keep ISO treatment, exercise within 3 months after you leave, or 1 year after a permanent and total disability. A later exercise, if your plan allows it, is taxed as an NSO.

What is the $100,000 rule for ISO?

The $100,000 rule limits ISO treatment to options on $100,000 of stock, valued at grant, that first become exercisable in one calendar year. That is usually the year they vest. Options over the limit are taxed as NSOs.

It counts every plan of your employer, its parent and its subsidiaries. If options on $150,000 of stock first vest in 2026, $100,000 are ISOs and $50,000 are NSOs.

IRS Publication 525 does not say which shares are which when options are split, but a Treasury regulation does. Unless your company designates them, the shares you buy first count as ISO shares. So check that Form 3921 lists only those.

Are ISO and NSO the same?

No, ISOs and NSOs are taxed differently, though both let you buy shares at a fixed price. An ISO must meet the rules in Section 422, and an option that does not is taxed as an NSO. One grant can be part ISO and part NSO.

Which is better, an ISO or an NSO?

An ISO is better for you when you can hold the shares for both periods and afford the AMT.

  • Hold, and the ISO wins. The whole gain is taxed at 0%, 15% or 20%, against wage rates of up to 37%.
  • Sell quickly, and the ISO still skips payroll tax. No withholding is required, so set the tax aside.
  • A large ISO exercise can bring an AMT bill. It can come before you sell anything. See how much you can exercise before the AMT.
  • NSOs are simpler. There is no AMT and no holding period to meet.

The 2027 AMT exemption is $93,000 single and $144,700 joint. Exercising across December and January uses two years of room.

When does each step happen?

WhenWhat happens
December 31, 2026ISO shares exercised in 2026 and still held count for the 2026 AMT
3 months after you leaveLast day to exercise with ISO treatment
1 year after exerciseNSO shares sold after this are long-term
2 years from grant and 1 from exerciseISO shares sold after both are fully long-term
10 years after grantLatest expiry for an ISO, or 5 years for an owner of over 10%

What should you do now?

  • Check your grant agreement for which options are ISOs and which are NSOs.
  • Before you exercise ISOs you plan to keep, estimate your 2026 AMT.
  • Before you exercise NSOs, plan the cash for the exercise price and any tax not withheld.
  • If you leave your job, write down the 3-month date for your ISOs.

See our guides to ISO taxes and NSO taxes, compare RSUs and stock options, or meet our equity compensation CPAs.

Sources.