Valim Book a call

Ex-Big Four CPA led, AI-enabled tax services for modern businesses & individuals.

Blog

S corp vs LLC: which saves more tax in 2026, and when to switch

S corp vs LLC is a tax choice, since an LLC can elect S corp status. Here is when the switch saves money, what it costs, and when to file Form 2553.

Vishant Mehta, CPA, Ex-Big 4

Published

  • S corp
  • LLC
  • small business tax
  • self-employment tax
  • Form 2553
  • entity choice

Watch in 3 minutes

S corp vs LLC is not a choice between two kinds of company. An LLC is a business formed under state law. An S corp is a federal tax status that an LLC can elect on Form 2553. So the real question is whether your LLC should keep its default tax treatment or elect S status.

Electing S status saves tax when your profit is well above a reasonable salary for your work. Only the salary owes Social Security and Medicare tax. To be an S corp from January 1, 2027, an LLC files Form 2553 by March 15, 2027.

RuleOne-owner LLCAs an S corp
Federal returnSchedule CForm 1120-S
Your payProfit, no salarySalary, then payouts
Tax on your work15.3% of 92.35% of profit15.3% of salary only
QBI deductionOn the profitNot on salary
OwnersAnyoneUp to 100, with limits

Figures are for 2026. In both cases the 12.4% Social Security part stops at $184,500 of earnings, and the 2.9% Medicare part has no cap. An LLC with two or more owners is a partnership by default and files Form 1065, which Form 1120-S replaces if it elects.

Do you pay more taxes as an LLC or S corp?

By default, a one-owner LLC pays more tax once profit is well above a fair salary, because self-employment tax reaches the whole profit. As an S corp, payroll tax falls only on the salary, and the rest of the profit owes none.

The saving depends on the salary, as this 2026 example shows. One owner files single, has no other income and takes the standard deduction.

Profit before salaryS corp salaryFederal tax saved
$60,000$40,000$1,671
$60,000$50,000None ($26 more)
$150,000$100,000$1,442
$150,000$70,000$7,031

At $150,000 of profit, the default LLC owner pays $37,607 of federal tax. At a $70,000 salary, the S corp owner pays $30,576. The example counts the company’s deduction for its half of payroll tax and the 20% qualified business income (QBI) deduction. It leaves out state tax and the cost of running payroll.

Here is what a CPA watches that the IRS pages do not spell out. A high salary can erase the whole saving, because the salary earns no QBI deduction. Payroll tax also falls on the full salary, while self-employment tax counts only 92.35% of profit.

What are the disadvantages of an S corp?

The main disadvantages are payroll, a separate return and stricter rules on owners and property.

  • Payroll. You must pay yourself a reasonable salary before taking distributions. That means Form 941 each quarter, plus Form 940 and a W-2 each year. If the salary is too low, the IRS can treat distributions as wages.
  • Another return. Form 1120-S is due every year, whatever the income. Filing a return due in 2027 late costs $260 per shareholder for each month or part of one, up to 12 months.
  • Owner limits. An S corp can have up to 100 shareholders and no nonresident aliens, partnerships or corporations among them. Every share must carry identical rights to distributions.
  • Property comes out taxed. Say an S corp gives an owner a building worth more than its basis. The company recognizes gain as if it sold the building, and the gain passes through to the owners. An LLC taxed as a partnership can usually distribute property tax-free.
  • Losses are capped. You deduct losses only up to your stock basis plus loans you made to the company.
  • Hard to undo. An LLC that revokes the election is taxed as a C corporation until it files Form 8832. It generally cannot elect S status again for five years.

Should I switch my LLC to an S corp?

Switch when your profit is well above a reasonable salary for your work. The tax saved must also beat the cost of payroll and an extra return. No IRS figure sets a break-even point.

  1. Price your role. Find what the business would pay someone else to do your job.
  2. Run the numbers at that salary. Compare your federal tax with and without the election, counting the QBI deduction.
  3. Add the running costs. Include a payroll service, the Form 1120-S fee and any state tax on S corporations.
  4. File Form 2553. Every owner must consent. An LLC that files Form 2553 needs no Form 8832.
  5. Start payroll. Pay the salary through payroll before you take distributions.

When is the deadline to elect S corp status?

The deadline is the 15th day of the third month of the tax year the election is for. For a calendar year starting January 1, that is March 15.

DateWhat it means
March 15, 2027Last day to file Form 2553 for S status from January 1, 2027
After March 15, 2027The election counts from 2028, unless the IRS grants relief
April 30, 2027First Form 941, for January to March 2027
March 15, 2028First Form 1120-S, for 2027

A new LLC has 2 months and 15 days from the day its first tax year starts. If you miss it with reasonable cause, Rev. Proc. 2013-30 lets you ask for relief, generally within 3 years and 75 days.

What should you do now?

  • If your 2026 profit is well above a fair salary for your role, model the election before March 15, 2027.
  • If the numbers work, file Form 2553 with every owner’s consent, and set up payroll before your first distribution.
  • Keep real estate and other property likely to grow in value out of the S corp.
  • If your LLC has two or more owners, check that the operating agreement gives every interest the same rights to distributions.

See our S corp tax guide, how LLC taxes work by default, and our small business CPAs for help.

Sources.